Are you looking for a detailed comparison of Shopify vs Square? You’ve landed on the right page.
These are the two most popular point-of-sale (POS) system providers and eCommerce store platforms. But the question is—which one is better?
The short answer is both are good but there are differences.
So, before choosing a side, it’s better to see both sides of the story. And that is exactly in this article we will help you with.
Ready? Let’s get started!
What is Square vs Shopify?
Before jumping right into the Square vs Shopify conflict, let’s take a moment to understand each service fully.
Square — a Complete Solution for Businesses.
Square is the largest business technology platform serving all kinds of businesses. It offers tons of services and applications that cater to businesses of all kinds and sizes. In a nutshell, Square is your business partner—that’s literally it. They make money when you do and offer all the services you may need to start or sustain a business. Such as:
- A PoS Service: To help you accept payment from anywhere, used by physical and online stores across industries.
- Square Capital: Allowing loans to eligible businesses.
- Payment Processing: Square allows setting up a simple process for creating merchant accounts. Upon signing up for a free Square account, you receive a sub or aggregate merchant account.
- Square Marketing Tools: Square’s marketing services allow for creating email campaigns, tracking analytics, sending promotion messages, and much more.
- Square Appointments: Square also offers dedicated services for service-based businesses that enable them to schedule and manage appointments with a built-in POS system.
By the time of writing, Square is available in the United States, Canada, Australia, Japan, the United Kingdom, the Republic of Ireland, France, and Spain. There is much more to the service. For those interested in learning more, please refer to the article below:
???? Also Read: What is Square? Detailed Look at Features [2025]
Shopify — an eCommerce Giant.
Shopify is a cloud-based eCommerce solution that provides a platform for businesses to start, run, and grow an online store. Similar to Square, it also offers tons of amazing features and benefits, such as:
- Drag and Drop Builder: Allows for creating appealing stores without coding.
- International Sales Tools: These tools help with customizing and managing your store(s) with multilingual themes, subfolders, translations, content for specific industries, and more.
- Search Engine Optimization: Shopify allows fantastic SEO benefits, enabling users to add titles, meta tags, and download additional addons to identify and fix SEO-related errors.
- Faster Load Times: Fast loading speed is a significant ranking factor, and Shopify stores are pretty fast.
- Social Media Integration: You can easily integrate with the store or mobile app with major social media platforms, such as Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter.
- Marketing Tools: Similar to Square, Shopify offers marketing tools, including email, SMS, and automation tools, and enables users to capture emails at checkout.
- Launchpad: It helps you schedule and automate marketing campaigns, product launches, and other events. We can say this is Shopify’s alternative to Square appointments.
- Integration Choice: Shopify can integrate with third-party payment processors.
Similar to Square, Shopify also offers a vast amount of services, and the aforementioned list is not the complete list of features. For a detailed description of the service, we recommend checking out the official website of the leading eCommerce platform.
Square vs Shopify — Pricing
Now, let’s talk pricing. And the value price. Simply put, the value you get for the amount of cash.
Square Pricing: Is Square Actually ‘Free?’
Setting up a Square account and a number of services that come with it are free. As said earlier, Square makes money when you do. Simply put, Square charges a processing fee. Every time you use Square for a transaction, Square charges a minimal processing fee. Here is the detailed information about the processing charges:
- Square charges 2.6% + $0.10 for in-person payments per transaction on taps, dips, or card swipes.
- For eCommerce stores, Square charges 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction for purchases made through eCommerce API.
- When manually entering a customer’s card details, Square charges 3.5% + $0.15 per transaction.
- When paying invoices—in-person or online—Square charges 3.3% + $0.30 per transaction.
- Square charges 1% for ACH Bank Transfers with a $1 minimum transaction.
Other fees vary based on the services. For example, email services cost based on the number of emails you send. Such as:
- 0-500 Customer Contacts: $15/month
- 501-1,000 Customer Contacts: $30/month
- 1,001-2,000 Customer Contacts: $40/month
- 2,001-4,000 Customer Contacts: $55/month
- 4,001-9,000 Customer Contacts: $90/month
Shopify Pricing: Avoidable and Unavoidable Fees.
Shopify has easy-to-understand pricing plans with four plans, Basic, Shopify, Advanced, and Plus, costing (billed annually) $19/mo, $49/mo, $299/mo, and $2,300/mo, respectively, with dedicated benefits with each plan. Or $25, $65, $399, and $2,300 if you pay monthly.
Apart from the subscription fee, Square also charges a processing fee on credit cards. Although, it widely varies depending on the plan and the type of card used. You can check the official document for accurate estimation.
Furthermore, a few more avoidable fees include paying for applications from the App Store that further enhance the functionality of your store. Or buying a premium theme, which can cost anywhere from $150 to $390. Alternatively, you can get a custom-built theme for your store, which could cost you around $2000 and $10,000.
Square vs Shopify: Ease of Usability
You might be quick to choose one after analyzing the prices, but we recommend sticking to the end because in this Square vs Shopify comparison, we will go beyond the prices and cliché. So, in this section, let’s see which one is better if you are just starting out.
Both Square and Shopify are designed to be user-friendly, but their ease of use varies based on your business needs and technical expertise.
Square: Quick and Easy.
As discussed earlier, Square offers a quick and easy setup. You can enter your business information, and before you know it, the stage is set for you to sell. To make it even better, a drag-and-drop editor is there to facilitate real-time adjustments, making it easy to use and accessible for users with minimal technical skills.
Many believe Square is the way to go, especially if you are just starting and do not have sufficient knowledge about building and managing an online store. Although naysayers say otherwise, it’s up to you and your business. Simply put, both are simple and easy to use. You better choose the one that matches your business needs.
Shopify: Takes Ample Time to Set Up.
This one may not be the choice if you want an easy and fast setup. The setup is a little long but easy to understand because its user-friendly interface and setup guides assist the user throughout the process.
However, it must be noted that acquiring the ‘perfect’ image of the store that you have in mind might not be readily achievable as it may take a lot of time and extensive coding knowledge—there is a reason custom themes cost that much. Apart from that, Shopify is also easy to use and beginner-friendly.
To summarize, Square is ideal for those seeking a quick, straightforward setup with minimal technical requirements. Shopify is better suited for users willing to invest time in setup and customization to leverage a comprehensive suite of e-commerce features. Your choice should align with your business’s specific needs and your comfort level with technology.
Square vs Shopify: Which Platform is Scalable?
Before this section, we were discussing which platform could offer a better start and better price for value. Now, let’s see which one is more suitable for your business’s rapid growth.
Square: Suitable for Small or Medium-sized Businesses
Square offers multiple services that may not be sufficient for a rapidly growing business. However, you should consider Square if you run a small to medium-sized business. It handles increased sales volume and multi-location operations effectively, but its advanced features may be limited for larger enterprises.
Square is widely known for integrating in-person and online sales, which makes it the perfect choice for physical stores that are just jumping into the eCommerce business and want to spend a chunk of investment setting up the account.
Another plus point is their pricing plans, as even if your business grows, you won’t have to pay more, as Square charges a processing fee, and no matter how much your business grows, you don’t have to pay a penny extra.
Shopify: Excellent Scalable Options
Unlike Square, Shopify offers easy scalability options. If your business grows, you just go and buy a better plan, and that’s literally it. The new and advanced plan will offer better and more features. For example, if you are on a Basic plan and staff account, you can switch to Shopify plan.
Shopify excels in scalability, catering to businesses of all sizes, from startups to large enterprises. With a vast app marketplace and powerful customization options, Shopify supports complex operations, international sales, and multi-channel selling, making it highly adaptable as your business grows.
To summarize, Square is an excellent choice for smaller businesses or those focusing on offline-online synergy, but its scalability might not be ample for enterprises with complex needs. Whereas Shopify is the go-to platform for businesses prioritizing long-term growth and scalable solutions for advanced e-commerce operations.
Conclusion
Choosing between Square and Shopify depends on your business’s specific needs, goals, and growth.
Simply put, Square shines as a user-friendly, cost-effective solution for small to medium-sized businesses, especially those combining offline and online sales. Its quick setup, transparent pricing, and practical tools make it an excellent choice for startups and physical stores trying to jump into e-commerce.
On the other hand, Shopify offers scalability and better customization options, making it ideal for businesses aiming for significant growth or requiring advanced features. Its comprehensive app marketplace and dedicated plans cater to businesses of all sizes.
Before making a decision, evaluate your business priorities and deeply understand the needs and budget. Both platforms have strengths and weaknesses, and the right choice will depend on how well each aligns with your present and future business needs.
Lastly, to connect Square with your WordPress, download WP EasyPay today!
Frequently Asked Questions
What is better, Square or Shopify?
Both have strengths and weaknesses. The best platform for you is the one that aligns well with your business needs. If you want to start small and early, Square is the better option for you. On the other hand, if you want easy scaling options and enhanced customization, you can go with Shopify.
Which platform provides better inventory management tools?
Square is renowned for its seamless inventory management tools, which are particularly suited for small- to medium-sized businesses. It allows real-time tracking of stock levels, low-stock alerts, and multi-location inventory management. On the other hand, Shopify offers advanced inventory management features, catering to businesses of all sizes. It supports tracking across multiple warehouses and bulk product uploads.
How much does Square charge per transaction?
Square charges 2.6% + 10 cents per transaction for every transaction, regardless of if the customer taps, dips, or swipes their card.
